Best Handicap Toilet: Reviews and Buying Guide

Best Handicap Toilet: Reviews and Buying Guide

If someone is handicapped, their life becomes increasingly difficult in a lot of places, including the bare necessities like visiting the toilet.

Accessible units can help a disabled person visit the bathroom without assistance, so if you share your home with them, be sure to check our comprehensive review of the best handicap toilets and choose the commode that will meet your demand!

Quick Picks

Editor’s Choice

2nd Best Choice — Best ADA Compliant Handicap Toilet

3rd Best Choice — Best Corner Handicap Toilet

American Standard 2886218.021 H2OptionTOTO CST243EF#12 EntradaSheffield Corner 2-Piece Dual Flush Elongated Toilet
  • 16.5’’ bowl height;
  • dual flush (0.9 GPF/1.28 GPF)
  • 16.25’’ round bowl meets ADA standards;
  • WaterSense & CALGreen certified
  • triangle-shaped tank to fit in the corner;
  • 0.8 GPF/ 1.6 GPF dual flush

What Makes a Toilet Accessible for Handicapped People?

Not every toilet is created equal, especially when it comes to features that make its exploitation by a handicapped person easier.

The main law that regulates the accessibility of furniture and facilities is the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

ADA Standards for Accessible Design contain a detailed description of things that make every item in the house accessible for a disabled person, whether they use a wheelchair or can walk by themselves.

So, here’s what it says about toilets:

  • Bowl height. The seat height of the toilet should be between 17-19 inches for bathrooms that are used by all family members. If the bathroom will be used by the disabled person only, you can install the toilet according to their comfort preferences and don’t have to abide by these rules (1).
  • Flush actuator. ADA standards recommend a flush actuator that doesn’t require tight grasping or twisting a wrist, therefore button actuators are more preferable to trip levers. But if you choose trip levers, be sure to install them for a person’s guiding hand. Also, the buttons shouldn’t be hard to press: the maximum force required to do this should be no more than 5 lbs (1).
  • Flush type. Pressure-assisted flush systems may be more preferable for a disabled person since they require less physical effort to trigger. Or, you may go for a more powerful gravity-fed flush.
  • Plumbing. Flush valves and plumbing fixtures can be located either behind the wall or to the side of the toilet. Locating the plumbing behind the toilet may make a person fall if they try to reach them (1).

5 Best Handicap Toilets on the Market

Best Overall — Editor’s Choice

American Standard 2886218.021 H2Option
Highlights:
  • 16.5’’ bowl height (without seat);
  • dual flush (0.9 GPF/1.28 GPF), WaterSense certified;
  • top-mounted push button flush actuator;
  • EverClean bowl surface resists stains and scratches;
  • different colors available.
American Standard 2886218.020 H2Option

Our list of the best handicap toilets opens with the H2Option by American Standard. This two-piece toilet with an elongated bowl provides a comfortable and accessible space for anyone who needs it. Plus, it has a dual flush with a convenient top actuator that is easy to reach and trigger.

H2Option is one of the best American Standard units, and it’s certified by WaterSense, meaning that it will save you some money on water bills. The secret behind this is a special PowerWash bowl that cleans itself with every flush and needs less water for the same efficiency.

Aside from that, the H2Option uses gravity-assisted flush with siphon jet action. This means that the bowl holds a small amount of water and uses it to optimize waste disposal when you trigger the flush. This results in smoother and quieter operation and prevents clogging.

Pros:

  • Helps save up to 20% of water per year
  • Operates without any unnecessary noises
  • Self-cleaning PowerWash bowl

Cons:

  • The seat is sold separately
  • Compliance with ADA standards is questionable

Best ADA Compliant Handicap Toilet

TOTO CST243EF#12 Entrada
Highlights:
  • 1.28 gallons per flush;
  • a round bowl is 16.25 inches high and meets the ADA requirements with the seat on;
  • 12’’ rough-in;
  • compliant with ADA & WaterSense;
  • good pick for small bathrooms.
TOTO CST243EF Entrada

The next unit that deserves its place on this list is the Entrada by TOTO. This toilet meets strict ADA regulations: its bowl measures 16.25 inches high, and when you add the seat, falls within the recommended 17’’-19’’ range. Plus, the bowl has a round shape, which is also more preferable for households with handicapped individuals.

As for other features, the Entrada is also WaterSense and CALGreen compliant. It uses 1.28 gallons per flush, which is a recommended amount in all 50 states, and can significantly reduce the water use in your home and save you some money on utility bills.

Plus, the Entrada is really easy to clean, which means that you will spend less water on this as well. It has a glossy finish that prevents the waste from sticking and is resistant to mold and bacteria, so you can clean it less often. Plus, the patented E-max flushing technology scrubs the bowl clean with each flush and maintains fresh looks for longer.

Pros:

  • Compliant with ADA and is a perfect pick for households with senior or handicapped people
  • 1.28-gallon gravity flush operates quietly and saves water
  • A round bowl takes less space than oblong and may fit into smaller bathrooms

Cons:

  • The flush valve is prone to leaks in the long run
  • the seat is sold separately
Highlights:
  • triangle tank for corner installation;
  • comes with a soft-closing seat;
  • WaterSense compliant 0.8 GPF/ 1.6 GPF flush;
  • Reno-Gloss bowl finish is resistant to stains and scratches;
  • an oblong bowl for more leg space.
Sheffield Corner 2-Piece Dual Flush Elongated Toilet

One of the foolproof ways of placing a standard toilet in a small bathroom is to install it in the corner. That’s why we included the Sheffield two-piece unit on our list of the best handicap toilets. It has a triangle tank that fits in the corner just right and allows you to enjoy comfortable use even in smaller spaces.

Aside from that, the Sheffield features a dual flush with a convenient top button actuator. The light flush uses 0.8 gallons, and the full flush removes the waste with a powerful 1.6-gallon flow and discards it through the glazed trapway.

The elongated bowl of the Sheffield unit has the Reno-Gloss finish and resists the stain-causing bacteria, so the bowl stays clean for longer.

Gravity-assisted flush ensures quiet and annoyance-free operation, and the soft-closing seat prevents any slamming sound and adds even more comfort.

Pros:

  • Fits smaller bathrooms without sacrificing the comfort of a full-size toilet
  • Meets ADA requirements and therefore is suitable for handicapped individuals
  • Soft-closing lid prevents slamming noises

Cons:

  • Installation hardware is sold separately
  • Some users report that the tank and the bowl may arrive in different colors

Best Pressure-Assisted Handicap Toilet

Kohler K-3493-96 Highline
Highlights:
  • 17.25’’ bowl meets ADA regulations;
  • pressure-assisted flush;
  • 1.4GPF helps reduce water use;
  • Class Five ® self-cleaning bowl;
  • available in 4 colors: White, Almond, Biscuit, and Black.
Kohler K-3493-96

The Kohler Highline series is present in this selection for two reasons. First, it has ADA compliant models — this toilet in particular with the bowl measuring 17.25 inches high. The second reason is their pressure-assisted system that delivers cleaner flush with less water.

The K-3493-96 packs the canister flush valve that delivers a powerful punch and flushes the bowl from all sides. This allows it to reach 100% bowl coverage with only 1.4 gallons per flush and meet the WaterSense certification. Thus, this Kohler toilet can save you up to 16,500 gallons of water annually.

Another great feature of the Highline is its oblong bowl with an extra glossy finish. It prevents the waster from sticking to the surface and scrubs itself with each flush, so the toilet stays clean for longer.

Finally, the Highline series offers you a modern design in various colors, so you will have no problems matching it with your bathroom interior.

Pros:

  • Universally comfortable and suitable for users of any age group
  • Reduces your water consumption
  • Stain-resistant and durable bowl finish

Cons:

  • Pressure-assisted systems tend to have a noisy flush
  • The price varies depending on the color

Best Wall-Hung Handicap Toilet

Swiss Madison SM-WT450 Ivy
Highlights:
  • the height can be adjusted from 15 to 19 inches while installing;
  • takes almost no space;
  • water-efficient dual flush (0.8 GPF /1.28 GPF);
  • soft-close and quick-release seat included;
  • includes all hardware needed for installation.
Swiss Madison Well Made Forever Ivy SM-WT450

The reason the Ivy wall-hung unit easily fits in our selection of the best handicap toilets is in its adjustable height. During the installation you can either leave it at the standard 15 inches or raise it to a comfortable and ADA compliant 17-19 inches, thus making it more accessible to everyone.

The wall-mounted design of the Ivy also makes it a perfect pick for small bathrooms. The toilet is 20.5 inches deep and 14.6 inches wide, and it doesn’t occupy the floor, which can make the whole space seem more lightweight. Plus, the tank is concealed behind the wall, which not only makes it space-saving, but contributes to the quieter performance as well.

Finally, the Ivy packs an eco-friendly dual flush system that uses 0.8 gallons for partial flush and 1.28 gallons for full flush. This gives you more control over the water you use and helps save some money on the water bills in the long run.

The Ivy is available in White and Black colors and can easily fit into any bathroom thanks to its modern and minimalist design.

Pros:

  • Adjustable height range makes the toilet ADA compliant and accessible
  • Quiet operation thanks to a soft-close seat and the concealed tank
  • Measures only 20.5’’D x 14.6’’W and can fit into tiny spaces

Cons:

  • The installation requires rerouting the sewer hole in the wall
  • The tank and the carrying system are sold separately

How Can You Make a Toilet More Accessible for a Disabled Person?

If you cannot currently choose a handicapped toilet or want to make your current unit more accessible, here’s what you can do:

  • Install toilet handles. Toilet handles are a construction that is secured around the toilet bowl and creates a grab bar around the perimeter, so the person can use their upper body strength to lift themselves. 
  • Consider high-rise seats. If your toilet has a Standard 15-inch high bowl — you can purchase a high-rise seat that can compensate for the height difference. High-rise seats can add up to 5’’ in height and can meet the ADA’s requirements.
  • Try toilet risers. Another way to raise the height of your commode is by choosing a toilet riser. This is a rectangular fixture that goes under the toilet base. This method is more resourceful but allows you to use the toilet with a regular seat. 
  • Expand the doorways. The standard bathroom door width is 32’’. However, to make it more accessible to a person who uses a wheelchair or a walker, you should expand the doorway to at least 36 inches (2).

Things that Make a Handicap Toilet More Comfortable to the Rest of the Family

Flush Type

A flushing system is the easiest way to regulate water consumption in the family. Thankfully, most of the modern toilets are WaterSense compliant and use 1.28 or 1.6 gallons per flush. Or, you can take a step further and choose a dual-flush system that will save you even more water.

As for the type, pressure-assisted systems tend to be more efficient,  but they also make a loud noise while flushing. If this is a concern for you, choose standard gravity flush toilets: they’re way quieter.

Ease of Cleaning

Modern toilets have an extra glossy glaze on the bowl, which prevents the waste from adhering. This, combined with a powerful cyclonic flush, helps maintain the toilet clean between the deep scrubbing.

Also, you may want to choose a skirted toilet with a concealed trapway or a single-piece commode that doesn’t have hard-to-reach crevices. Or even go for a self-cleaning toilet that uses cleaning cartridges and scrubs itself so you don’t have to touch anything.

Design

The toilet design is a matter of personal taste, but each form factor has unique features that can direct your choice in their favor:

  • One-piece. Quicker to install and compact, less prone to leaks, but may weigh more than 100 pounds, so it may be a problem to install them single-handedly.
  • Two-piece. Cheaper and easier to install for a single person, but cleaning might be more time-consuming. Also, they’re more prone to leaks, since the water supply line is exposed.
  • Wall-hung. Incredibly minimalist and quiet, since the tank is concealed behind the wall, which makes them a good pick for small bathrooms. However, installation requires rerouting the waste pipe into the wall and can be quite costly.

FAQ

When a person has weak legs or limited mobility, it might be hard for them to sit down or get up from a regular 15-inch toilet. Squatting on a toilet engages many body muscles, and if a person doesn’t feel them properly or doesn’t have enough strength, they may fall. So a higher toilet is more advisable.

As long as the wall-mounted unit meets ADA regulations on 17-19’’ height and has a recommended clearance around, a disabled person can easily use it.

Handicap toilets don’t differ too much from the standard units in terms of costs. The models we reviewed here fall within the $200-$500 price range, so you can still purchase a decent commode even if you’re tight on budget.

Not really. While some of the ADA compliant toilets may be labeled as ‘comfort height’ or ‘right height’, this isn’t always the case. A comfort height toilet can be 17’’ high but ADA compliant units add a couple of inches more and may not fit an average able-bodied person.

This usually boils down to personal preferences, but most people, including those with mobility issues, prefer an oblong bowl as it provides more space for legs. However, you can use the round bowl as well, especially for smaller bathrooms.

Owner - Mary O. Frazier

Founder

Mary O. Frazier

Mary O. Frazier — lead author of our website, connoisseur of interior design and plumbing. I will tell you the most interesting and important facts about household items. She reads a lot, plays chess and collects useful information for you. You can read more about her here.

Leave Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *